- 24/7 Free Consultation: (888) 424-5757 Tap Here To Call Us
If Someone Pulls Out in Front of You and You Hit Them, Is It Your Fault?
In the aftermath of a car accident, your immediate priority should be your health and safety. Once you’ve confirmed you’re not seriously injured, the question of fault naturally arises. Fault may determine how damages are paid, whether those damages include medical bills, lost wages, or property damage.
One common type of car accident is a rear-end collision, in which the driver in front has just pulled onto the roadway from a side street or driveway, and a vehicle already traveling in that direction collides with the back of their car. While the driver who entered the roadway is generally considered at fault, proving this in an insurance claim can be challenging.
Moreover, if the driver on the main road was speeding, they might share or bear full responsibility for the automobile accident.
The Presumption of Fault in Rear-End Accidents
A rear-end accident is generally assumed to be the fault of the driver in the rear. Presumably, if you hit a vehicle traveling in front of you, even if they hit their brakes suddenly, you should have left enough space between the cars to stop before the collision.
The other driver’s insurance company can easily claim that you did not allow a safe distance between the two vehicles, diminishing your chance of compensation from insurance claims. The presumption of fault in rear-end accidents makes this type of collision complex, so you will need substantial evidence to support your claim that the other driver is at fault.
Exceptions to the Rule
There are exceptions to this presumption. For example, a mechanical failure in your vehicle that prevents you from stopping in time could put the manufacturer or an auto repair shop at fault for the car accident.
If the lead driver stops suddenly for no reason or engages in aggressive braking behavior, it may also be their fault. Unsafe lane changes by the lead driver can also mean they are liable for a rear-end accident.
Lastly, if a driver pulls onto a roadway and fails to yield to oncoming traffic, they are likely at fault for any resulting rear-end collision, though proving this can be challenging.
Factors Influencing Fault Determination
Determining fault decides which insurance company will cover damages from the car accident. In most states, the at-fault driver must use their policy to cover damages for the other parties in the crash. Here are some factors that will influence the fault outcome.
Speed and Following Distance
The speed of both vehicles and the distance between them play crucial roles in determining fault in a collision. If either driver is speeding, they’re likely to be held liable. A safe following distance is essential for the rear driver. If they are too close to the driver ahead, they are not giving themselves enough time to react to unexpected changes.
Adhering to traffic laws, posted speed limits, and safe driving distances are essential to protect you from liability in a car crash.
Visibility and Road Conditions
Driving conditions will also affect fault in a car accident. Poor visibility due to rain, snow, or fog could make it harder for drivers to see cars ahead of them. Inclement conditions like slippery roads could cause a vehicle to slide further than its standard braking would allow, leading to a collision with the leading car.
These adverse conditions complicate liability in car accidents, as drivers must adjust their behavior to suit the conditions.
Driver Conduct and Actions
The primary factor in determining fault is the conduct of the drivers. If one driver pulls out in front of another when they should yield, the accident is probably their fault.
Unfortunately, if it ends up being a rear-end accident, it could be tough to prove the other motorist pulled out in front of you without witnesses or footage of the collision. Illegal maneuvers, distracted driving, or impairment will influence driver liability in a car accident.
Poor driver conduct is the most common cause of vehicle accidents, so practice defensive driving tactics to avoid collisions. At the very least, if you are hit by another vehicle, your safe conduct will reduce the risk of being found at fault for the accident.
The Role of Evidence in Determining Fault
Evidence is the key to securing compensation in rear-end collisions where a driver pulls out in front of you. The more data you gather, the better your chances are.
If your case becomes a civil lawsuit, you must prove that the accident was more likely than not the other driver’s fault. An experienced personal injury lawyer can help you gather and present evidence of the other driver’s negligence. Here are some examples of such evidence:
Police Reports and Witness Statements
A police report can be the most helpful evidence in your car accident claim. The report of the investigating police officer will establish the events that led to the crash, including if the other driver pulled onto a roadway before traffic had cleared.
Witness statements are also essential if people saw the crash happen in real-time, so interview witnesses after the collision and record their statements and contact information to support your claim. The testimony of one witness could have a significant impact if you need to determine liability, so speak to passersby while still at the accident scene to obtain witness accounts.
Vehicle Damage and Accident Reconstruction
Damage to the vehicles involved in the car accident can reveal much about the nature of the collision. For example, if there is a dent in the side of the car that pulls out in front of you, this would indicate that the vehicle was entering the roadway when it got hit, which could help your case.
There are also accident reconstruction experts who can look at an accident scene, piece together the evidence, and recreate the circumstances of the crash to determine fault. If a car pulls out in front of you before an accident, testimony from a reconstruction specialist could demonstrate how the accident occurred.
Traffic Camera Footage or Dashcam Recordings
The best type of evidence in a car accident case is footage, especially in cases with conflicting accounts of the accident. If an accident victim can obtain traffic camera footage or dashcam recordings of the car crash, they can easily show whose fault the collision was.
For example, proving fault if someone pulls out in front of your car suddenly is simple if you have a dashcam since the footage will show that the other driver failed to yield as you approached.
Shared Fault and Comparative Negligence
In some states, shared fault statutes allow multiple parties to share responsibility for a car accident. Even if one driver is more responsible, another driver could share a portion of the fault. This law is also considered comparative negligence.
The Concept of Comparative Negligence
With comparative negligence, there is usually more than one negligent driver. However, the decision process may determine that one party displayed more negligence than the other.
When insurance adjusters or civil judges assign fault to multiple parties, some states have laws requiring victims to pursue damages only if they share less than 50% of the fault. This concept protects drivers from being found fully liable for car collisions when other parties contributed to the accidents as well.
How Comparative Negligence Affects Compensation
In cases of shared fault, such as when someone pulls out in front of you, the outcome depends on the percentage of fault assigned to each driver. Many states will adjust potential compensation by the percentage of fault.
For example, if you were determined to be 30% at fault for the accident while the other driver was 70% at fault, you can pursue compensation in these states since you were less than 50% responsible. However, your potential claim settlement will be reduced by your percentage of fault, in this case, 30%.
Request Expert Legal Assistance!
Car accident cases are complicated when you need to determine fault. If someone pulls out in front of your vehicle when they are supposed to yield, it could be challenging for you to prove fault, especially if the result is a rear-end collision.
Convincing the other driver’s insurance company that you are not responsible for the accident could be an uphill battle affecting your insurance or injury claims for compensation.
If you have suffered serious injuries or property damage in a car crash, you need an experienced car accident lawyer on your side to help establish negligence and fight for fair compensation.
Our personal injury law firm can help you prove liability in a motor vehicle accident and increase your chances of winning a fair settlement. A knowledgeable car accident attorney will help you gather witness statements, obtain a copy of the accident report, and assess your damages to help you build a stronger case.
Call our Chicago car accident attorneys today at 888-424-5757 or complete our contact form to request your free case review.
All content undergoes thorough legal review by experienced attorneys, including Jonathan Rosenfeld. With 25 years of experience in personal injury law and over 100 years of combined legal expertise within our team, we ensure that every article is legally accurate, compliant, and reflects current legal standards.